Showing posts with label BHM 2018. Show all posts
Showing posts with label BHM 2018. Show all posts

The Portrayal of Black Characters in Teen Shows

When you're a teenager you look to the media for ideas about beauty and fashion, but you also pick up ideals about friendship and relationships. Too bad most of the teen shows in the U.S. are marketed toward white teens. Take a second, without Google, name a teen show other than Grown-ish that stars a black actor or actress.

Introduction

I already talked about teen movies, now I'm coming back to teen and children's shows. Representation matters, especially to young children and teens who are just navigating the waters of self discovery and establishing self worth. It's annoying to never see yourself reflected in your favorite sitcoms and even more disheartening to know that studios have forgotten about your demographic. Growing up there were few shows I remember that had a black lead, and those that did had an all black cast.

Shows Marketed for Black Youth

Off the top of my head Sister, Sister, Smart Guy, One on One, The Famous Jett Jackson, and That's So Raven, are the shows that come to mind from my youth. The only current show I can think of that is specifically for teens that has a black main character is Grown-ish. While the other shows all have their place in my heart, Sister, Sister really takes the cake for me (it might also be the longest running of the shows I've listed). The show follows twins Tia and Tamera as they navigate through all the ups and downs of high school and on through college. It is to me what Boy Meets World or Saved By the Bell is to whites who grew up in the same era.

The Countless Other Shows

Though I love the shows mentioned above, the most mentioned and memorable shows from my youth are almost exclusively white. Boy Meets World, Growing Pains, Gilmore Girls, One Tree Hill, Dawson's Creek, Saved By the Bell, Blossom, Sabrina the Teenage Witch, The Lizzie McGuire Show, Even Stevens... If you pick randomly from an exhaustive list of teen shows from my generation, chances are you'll pull a show with a majority white cast and a token minority. From what I've seen, the next generation of shows (Pretty Little Liars, So Awkward, The Vampire Diaries, Girl Meets World, Riverdale etc.) aren't doing much better. For example, The CW re-envisioned Josie and the Pussycats as an all black group and fell into the trap of creating sassy black women stereotypes of them, but they didn't touch the four main characters—Archie, Jughead, Betty, and Veronica. So once again, we have black teens in the background while the white teens get to shine in the spotlight. That's the message most of these shows send.

Ramifications

I'm not going to harp on how this effects black children and teens psychologically because I think anybody can figure that out. We have countless campaigns trying to teach women to love themselves despite the distorted images we see in the media, so you can connect the dots that lack of racial representation is also damaging. What I want to talk about instead, is how enables young white stars to kick off their careers in a way black stars do not. Let's talk about Disney, specifically. Disney churns out teen celebrities (particularly female teen celebrities) the way factories churn out parts. Granted, many of them end up with a heap of problems, it is still a launch pad for building a career in the industry. Very few black stars have this opportunity. When I think of black actors and actresses, they are usually older, with teens not represented.

Let's go back to Disney. I can think of 4 black teens to appear on Disney recently: Raven Symone, Keke Palmer, China McClain, and Zendaya. When Raven Symone began working with Disney, staring in That's So Raven, Zenon: Girl of the 21st Century and The Cheetah Girls, she was already a household name for black viewers thanks to The Cosby Show. She had already been in The Little Rascals and Doctor Dolittle before Disney cast her as a supporting character in Zenon: Girl of the 21st Century in 1999. Keke Palmer, who was never given her own show on Disney but starred in the TV movie Jump In, was also already a household name for black viewers by the time Disney cast her. She had already starred in Akeelah and the Bee as well as appeared in Madea's Family Reunion and Law and Order. China Anne McClain also appeared in Madea's Family Reunion, as well as Daddy's Girls, A Dennis the Menace Christmas, and House of Payne before appearing as an extra on Disney's Hannah Montana. She would go on to appear in NCIS before getting a supporting role in Disney's Jonas and Wizards of Waverly Place before starring in Disney's A.N.T. Farm and receiving a starring role in the TV Movie How to Build a Better Boy. Zendaya is the only of these ladies to get her start in the industry by the Disney Channel. She was able to costar in Shake it Up, then go on to star in K.C. Undercover and Zapped.[4] Whether coincidental, or evidence of colorism, Zendaya is also the lightest of the aforementioned black women.

In contrast, stars like Kirsten Storms (Zenon: Girl of the 21st Century), Miley Cyrus (Hannah Montana), Selena Gomez (Wizards of Waverly Place), Rowan Blanchard (Girl Meets World), and Christy Carlson Romano (Kim Possible, Even Stevens), came to Disney with significantly shorter resumes. Kiersten Storms was relatively unknown, having on 2 minor credits before being cast first in Disney's Sing Me A Story With Belle, then as the lead in Zenon: Girl of the 21st Century.[5] Miley Cyrus had only 2 supporting roles before starring in Hannah Montana.[6] Rowan Blanchard and Selena Gomez both appeared in the Spy Kids franchise before appearing on Disney, though I don't know if they were recognizable faces from these appearances.[7][9] Selena Gomez appeared on Barney and Friends as well, but once again, that didn't catapult her into household name recognition.[7] Christy Carlson Romano, who was a Disney megastar during my pre-teen years, had only minor roles (some of which were so minor she was uncredited) before landing the lead in Even Stevens.

Black teen stars are basically already established by the time Disney takes note, while their white counterparts are usually still trying to graduate from guest roles. Why is that? Sure, you could argue that some of Disney's white stars (like Bella Thorne, for example) had impressive resumes before appearing on the network, but you can't deny that black Disney stars are not promoted the way the others are. Halloweentown, a franchise which managed to have no minority characters in the majority of the movies, was given three sequels. High School Musical which features minorities as secondary characters but centers around the white main characters, was given two sequels,—one of which was released in theaters—a spin off movie, and a fourth movie plus a TV show is in the works.[10] Contrarily, the heavily diverse and equally successful Cheetah Girls only received 2 sequels (and no theatrical release).

Shows From Other Countries

If you're looking for diversity in a teen show, you should look to other countries. Canada's Backstage is great at providing diversity without focusing on race or making the characters stereotypical. The U.K.'s Free Rein is also a great find, placing people of color in the world of horse training.

Thoughts for the Road

Lately, it's been a "thing" to reboot beloved series from my generation's childhood. Full House, Gilmore Girls, and Boy Meets World have all gotten a reboot. As of yet, no show from this era staring a black character (or even having black regulars in their cast) have been remade... Here's to hoping the Sister, Sister reboot comes to fruition.[11]

References

  1. "Raven Symone". IMDB; visited February 2018
  2. "Keke Palmer". IMDB; visited February 2018
  3. "China Anne Mclain". IMDB; visited February 2018
  4. "Zendaya". IMDB; visited February 2018
  5. "Kirsten Storms". IMDB; visited February 2018
  6. "Miley Cyrus". IMDB; visited February 2018
  7. "Selena Gomez". IMDB; visited February 2018
  8. "Christy Carlson Romano". IMDB; visited February 2018
  9. "Rowan Blanchard". IMDB; visited February 2018
  10. Noelle DeVoe. "Everything We Know About "High School Musical 4" So Far". Seventeen. February 12, 2018
  11. Karla Rodriguez. "Tia Mowry Gives an Update About the ‘Sister, Sister’ Reboot: ‘Everything Is in Place’". US Weekly. January 27, 2018

Book Review: Hidden Figures

Hidden Figures is a phenomenal story. Whether you learn about the black female computers who solidified the U.S.'s space program during the height of the civil rights area from the book or the movie, you really should learn about them. Katherine Johnson, Dorothy Vaughn, and Mary Jackson are true American Heroines.
Hidden Figures by Margot Lee Shetterly
There is absolutely no mystery about it, Hidden Figures is my favorite movie of all time. I saw it twice in theaters, bought it as soon as it was released on DVD, and watch it probably once a month. As a black female who holds degrees in Mathematical Sciences, Computer Engineering, and Computer Science, it's no wonder the movie was so powerful to me.

Last May, I had the privilege of attending a workshop for women in computing and Margot Lee Shetterly, the author of the book for which the movie is based (also called Hidden Figures), was one of the speakers. We were given the opportunity to meet her, relay our gratitude for such and impactful book, and of course, get autographs. My plan was to read the book on the plane ride back home. Instead, I fell asleep from exhaustion and didn't get a chance to revisit the book until recently. I'm glad I finally got around to reading the book, because it's just as awesome as the movie!

The book is way more informative than the movie. We don't just learn about the three main women, but about several black women and even a few white women. Each of the women in the book contributed to the success of the other women and are praised for tasks such as being the first first female to author a paper within NASA. In the book, we get to see these accomplishments laid out in more detail and understand just how much these ladies achieved. In addition, the book allows us to see the women as more than just scientists, showing Mary Jackson as a devoted Girl Scout troop leader and Katherine G. Johnson as a dedicated member of her sorority. The book also incorporates major events in US history, such as the Brown v. Board of Education ruling to the lives of the women working at NASA. After watching the movie, you feel inspired and you know about 3 trailblazers, but after reading the book you'll know about so much more.

A major difference between the book (which is based on fact, by the way) and the movie is the powerful scene in which Katherine confronts her boss about the unfairness of having to walk such a distance (I think it was a mile) to use the "colored" bathroom. In the movie, this is followed by the white supervisor dismantling the signs the segregated the bathrooms and delivering the line "here at NASA, we all pee the same color." It's a powerful scene and speaks volumes to the experiences and injustices these women were subjected to. Which is why I still love the scene even though it never happened...

In fact, Katherine never followed the rules and used the white-only bathroom from the time she arrived at NASA (then called NACA) until she retired. While I think a scene depicting this could have played out even better, with Katherine playing an active role in desegregation rather than the passive role of only speaking out when prompted, the real reason she was able to circumvent the segregated bathrooms, according to the book, was because she was fairer skinned and able to pass for white. I think brining that tidbit into the movie would have been less impactful. Don't get me wrong, there's absolutely nothing wrong with being a fair-skinned black person, but due to the history of colorism in the U.S., I don't think showing a woman who could be mistaken for white as the lead in a story about black triumph would have been nearly as inspiring to the thousands of little black girls who won't be mistaken for white. So, I'm overjoyed that Hollywood chose the "more obviously black" Taraji P. Henson to play the role of adult Katherine and Lidya Jewett to play young Katherine. Impact wise, it makes a difference. By participating in the West Computing Group, Katherine G. Johnson did not try to pass for white and was known to be black, and I think was important to keep that aspect in focus for the movie.

The other major change I found between the book and the movie was how closely the book hit home, giving it more of a bittersweet feel than the triumph I feel after watching the movie. The movie presents us with crowning achievements: Dorothy Vaughn gets her promotion, Mary Jackson becomes an engineer, and Katherine Johnson sends a man into space! The book, however, reminds me of how little things have changed for women and black women in the sciences. Full of expositions explaining their philosophies and how each woman thought, the book talks about the struggles of being a black female at NASA during the Jim Crow era, but it doesn't sound much different than the experiences I've had today. Black people, both men and women, make up less than 2% of the technical jobs in Silicon Valley.[1] It was quite depressing to read sentences about how alienated these women felt embarking on their career in the 50's, knowing I've thought the same things. How can so much have been accomplished and yet so little has changed?

Nonetheless, I feel that this should be required reading at high schools everywhere! It is deeply moving and deeply inspirational.

References

  1. Julia Carrie Wong. "Segregated Valley: the ugly truth about Google and diversity in tech". The Guardian. August 7, 2017

Zootopia: Are Minorities Prey or Predator?

Zootopia is probably far from your mind since it came out quite a while ago, but it's such a great movie to ignite conversations about race relations, discrimination, and prejudice. There aren't "black" or "white" characters in the movie, but it says a lot about race, especially for a kid's movie, hence it's inclusion of this year's Black History Month series.

Introduction

I know, Zootopia came out ages ago and you've moved on, but this movie has so much to do with the experience of minorities (specifically black people) in the U.S., that I had to talk about it while we're on the subject of the media's portrayal of black people. Within seconds of tuning in to Zootopia, it was obvious that prey and predator was an allegory for race relations in the US. It seems pretty self explanatory, but after seeing the movie multiple times and having time to really think about it, I realized it's much more complicated than it seems.

The Allegory

The Relationships in America

It's no secret that minorities are treated differently in the U.S., especially after the election of Donald Trump. Zootopia builds on these differences to build an allegorical version of the U.S. for the viewer. The main character, Judy, can't wait to live in Zootopia because of the lure of equality, just as people immigrate to the U.S. in search of the "American Dream." Upon her arrival, Judy quickly learns that things aren't as different as she thought it would be. In the world of Zootopia the imbalance between the majority and minorities is realized as a power struggle between predator and prey. Most people assume the predators, who are wrongly accused of evil, are minorities, and the prey, who do the accusing, are the majority.[1] However, I noticed a strong argument for the opposite.

Predators or Prey

I get why people came to the conclusion that predators are the minority. Realistically, prey make up the majority in the animal kingdom. Also, the fear the prey have for the predators matches the way white supremacist speak of black people. In the same year Zootopia was released, Hilary Clinton was put in check for referring to black youth as "super predators" during her husband's enforcement of mass incarceration.[5] This is almost identical to the plot of the movie: predators are called predators and locked up for the good of the prey. On top of that, in the end, the prey are caught framing the predators to look more vicious than they really are. This fits the themes of racial profiling, Islamaphobia, etc. But, let's look at three things that actually point to the prey being "minorities" and the predators being the majority.

1) Most of the cops are predators

Judy is laughed at when she says she wants to be a cop because bunnies aren't cops. When she joins the police force, most of the officers shown are predators—even the guy at the desk is a jaguar. This was exactly the issue in Ferguson, MO during the Michael Brown incident. They found that despite the city being 67% black, the police force was 94% white.[1]

2) Careers

We see prey as farmers, celebrities (re: athletes and entertainers), and mobsters (re: organized crime). The assistant mayor (a sheep) is treated poorly by the mayor (a lion), and given a storage closet for an office. This fits the stereotype of black people being entertainers, thugs, and in subservient positions. We do get a glance of an elephant owning an ice cream shop, but that's the point of the movie: you can't assume something about someone based on stereotypes. Just because most of the prey were not CEOs doesn't mean none were. Similarly, just because most black people you meet aren't CEOs doesn't mean there isn't a black CEO somewhere.

3) Comments tying in the movies' theme

There are two lines that make it obvious the movie is dealing with racism, and both are directed at predators in defense of prey. Judy (prey) tells a jaguar (predator) that only bunnies can call other bunnies cute. This is a reference to the idea that only black people can call other black people the n-word. Judy later tells Nick (predator) that he can't just touch a sheep's (prey) wool. This is a reference to black women complaining about strangers touching our natural hair without permission. In both cases the prey is the minority, not the predator.

4) The prey are trying to get power

The main reason I think we don't want to say that minorities are prey is because the villains turn out to be prey. Now whether the directors were trying to make a statement about Black Lives Matter, subtly hinting at a conspiracy led attempt to fan racial tensions (like Charles Manson [6]), or just trying to create a mystery for the plot, I don't know (I don't really see any parallels between Black Lives Matter and the criminal operation, but it does seem a little odd that they would throw this in without meaning). Nonetheless, it reminds us of the main point, the predators had power and the prey did not. The whole reason for their ornate scheme was to take power from the predators. Like minorities, the prey in the movie have never had power, it is the predators who have been running the show the whole time.

Putting it Together

It's beautiful because you can argue valid points from each side because prejudice exists within both the predators and prey (majority and minority). The movie creates a spring board for the discussion of racism. We often see white people cringe and retreat at the mentioning of the word and perhaps thats because people are using different definitions. The dictionary definition of racisim is "a belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race" but it also says it could simply be "racial prejudice or discrimination." Most people fall under a different definition of racism—"a political or social system founded on racism"—and thus, many conflate hegemony into the definition of racism. In this definition, racism is when a person has power to oppress someone based upon their prejudices. This is where the popular stance that "black people can't be racist" comes from. Minorities don't have the power to oppress white people. We witnessed that in the past election. A man who incited racial violence and condemned members of every minority group won the election.

Many people are put off by the word racism because they don't think they're superior and they don't think they have prejudices, but as Zootopia elegantly displays, we all have prejudices. The issue is when we aren't aware of those prejudices and we allow them into power. This fuels systematic racism and prevents us from truly moving into a post-racial society.

The "Default" Race

Recently, I saw this post on Dorkly, where they featured artists' reimagining of the characters as humans. The comment section was overwhelmed by people upset about the fact that all of the artists reimagined the characters as white. Some commented that it made sense because they mapped the character's color palette, and "you can't have a non-white ginger." (Clearly someone has been living under a rock). The "natural" inclination to draw the characters as white humans comes from the idea that white is the default race. The danger of allowing yourself to cling to this idea is that everyone else is then devalued or lessened in your subconscious.

Minority Talent

Zoootpia is supposed to be the epitome of diversity, so we would expect a diverse cast providing the voices for its inhabitants, right? The movie casts three black actors (two being the well known Idris Elba and Octavia Spencer), a Latina actress (Shakira), and an Asian and white actor (Tommy Chong) in supporting roles, however both lead character are played by white actors.

References

  1. Katie Sanders. "Ferguson, Mo., has 50 white police officers, three black officers, NBC's Mitchell claims". PunditFact. August 2014
  2. "Racism". Merriam-Webster. 2017
  3. "Hegemony". Merriam-Webster. 2017
  4. Todd VanDerWerff. "Zootopia wants to teach kids about prejudice. Is it accidentally sending the wrong message?". Vox. March 7, 2016
  5. Anne Gearan and Abby Phillip. "Clinton regrets 1996 remark on ‘super-predators’ after encounter with activist". The Washington Post. February 25, 2016
  6. Linley Sanders. "Charles Manson is Dead; What Was His 'Helter Skelter' Race War Plan?". Newsweek. November 20, 2017

Segregated TV = Segregated Reality

Once I was complaining about how racially monolithic a particular show was. Then I realized, it didn't bother that the show didn't include any minority characters; it bothered me because for most people, that's what their world actually looks like.

Introduction

When I started this post, there were so many things I wanted to get in to, but then the post kept getting longer and longer... So I tried to get to the heart of what I wanted to say. I could talk forever about the importance of "black" movies in our society or how awesome it is to see stories reimagined for minority audiences. Instead, I kept my focus on the three types of movies and shows I see in the industry, because I think once you recognize these types of movies the rest will come to you on it's own (I hope!). Each of these types of movies is a commentary (perhaps unintentionally) on our society. One represents the world I wished we lived in. One represents the world people think we live in. And one represents the reality of our society.

The Three Types of Movies

Movies fall into three different categories when it comes to race. I called them racially monolithic, racially inclusive, or racially blind,

Racially Monolithic

1989
Unfortunately, most movies are racially monolithic. In these movies there maybe a token character, but for the most part, the characters are all one color. The majority of movies, especially mainstream movies, are monolithically white, however, there are movies/shows that are monolithically black, Asian, or even Latino. As I mentioned in a previous post, sometimes the premise of a show or movie calls for this type of cast. My problem is that even when the situation doesn't mandate this type of cast, we still see it.

These movies, which make up the majority of what we see, are an unfortunate reminder of how segregated our country still is. Did you know that 75% of white people have no non-white friends?[7] Perhaps that's why we still have a very segregated world in the movies.

Racially Inclusive

My favorite type of movies are those that are racially inclusive. These movies feature a cast from various backgrounds and cultures without belaboring the plot. A franchise that did a great job with this is The Fast and Furious. I wrote a post detailing why I love the cast of this movie a while back, so I won't rehash that here.[1] The basic gist is that the cast contains white, black, Latino, and Asian characters that aren't stereotypical, and the movie never makes a point about race. In short, the movie seems to live in a true post-racial society.

Unfortunately, the only other movies or shows produced in the U.S. I can think of that looks like this are Lemonade Mouth and Big Hero 6. All other racially inclusive movies and shows that come to mind are produced in foreign countries: 3% (Brazil), Backstage (Canada), and Degrassi (Canada). This isn't to say that they don't exist, just that I have not seen them. They're definitely harder to find than racially monolithic movies.

Racially Blind

Have you ever seen Roger's & Hammerstein's Cinderella or Still Star-Crossed? If you have, it was probably jarring to you at first. Characters are obviously cast with complete disregard to race. It's like the casting director was colorblind. While the director may have chosen actors and actresses they truly liked without ever thinking about color, the end result is a bit garbled. Viewers spend half the movie trying to sort out the hows and whys, likely missing important details in the movie, because the blind casting doesn't take into account context, circumstances, or history.

In this version of Cinderella, Brandy plays the lead role of Cinderella. Her stepmother is played by Bernadette Peters, a white actress, which is still logically possible. However, Cinderella's stepsisters are played by Veanne Cox (white) and Natalie Desselle Reid (black). Although it seems a bit weird at first, it could still be possible for both women to be the biological daughters of a white woman. In general, black people span a large range of shades. As such, there are instances were siblings from one white parent and one black parent appear to be of a different race.[3] There's also the possibility that Cinderella's stepmom is on her third husband, which also makes sense given her conniving personality. Just when we thought we had it figured out, we meet the royal family. The prince is played by Paolo Montalban (Phillippino), the king is played by Victor Garber (white), and the queen is played by Whoopi Goldberg (black). Theoretically, the prince could be adopted, though it seems unlikely that an adopted child would be next in line for the throne. Historically speaking, the king's brother and/or nephews would probably have launched a campaign of legitimacy and stolen the crown from an adopted heir.[2]

Still Star Crossed, a TV show that picks up where Romeo and Juliet left off, has similar casting choices. In the world of this show, the Capulets and Montagues are racially diverse families which seem to have become so illogically rather than strategically. For example, in my family, it started with a generation that decided to marry interracially. Given this, my generation and the one after it, are automatically diverse. This is logical and makes sense; it became expected as soon as the interracial marriages took place. In Still Star-Crossed, however, the diversity isn't related to marriages across races at all; it just is.[4]

I find this method of casting interesting. On the one hand, I enjoy it because it reminds me of school and community plays where they simply cast the best person for each role. It projects a welcoming and inclusive atmosphere, where success is based on talent, not on color. In a world where most of the characters brought to life on screen are assumed to be white unless otherwise stated, racially blind casting allows minority actors and actresses to audition for the same number of roles their white counterparts may audition for. The more roles available to you, the more likely you are to earn one, and the more roles earned by minorities, the more representation we achieve.

On the other hand, the fact that when I begin these types of movies or shows I am confused and puzzled by these juxtapositions of race, says something about how deep into our subconscious race really is. If we truly lived in a post-racial America, we wouldn't think about color at all. The points I make about how the relationships could be possible wouldn't need thinking on because it would be common. As it is, we don't see such blending of races which causes us to find it "weird" subconsciously—and that's weird.

The Introduction of "Race Swapping"

2012
One of the most frustrating things in school was sitting in my English classes while we read "classics" which only featured white characters. The same annoyance strikes black viewers all the time, especially in previous years when minorities were given even less screen time. To bring some of these classic to black audiences, often a movies are remade with a black cast.

Examples

  • Steel Magnolias
  • The Wiz (remake of the 1939 Wizard of Oz)
  • Polly (remake of Pollyanna)
  • Death at a Funeral
  • Annie

A White Remake of a Black Movie

Interestingly, the opposite happened with Seventeen Again and 17 Again. Though, 17 Again isn't exactly a remake of of Seventeen Again but the plots are pretty similar! Chances are it's just a coincidence (like Friends With Benefits and No Strings Attached), however I wanted to mention it since I've met people who seem to think Seventeen Again is a remake of 17 Again. This is the one instance where the black movie came first.

Why These Movies Are Important

The same way women identify more with a seeing a female superhero (e.g. Wonder Woman), we identify with characters that look like us racially. Growing up I found movies like Polly to be incredibly inspiring. This is the only movie I remember as a kid that was about a black child. If your memory of characters that look like you is like mine you understand the importance. If not, try to imagine a childhood where all the stories are about someone else.

References

  1. Ree Hughes. "The Fast and Furious: Diversity in Hollywood". PSALMS to God. May 31, 2015
  2. "Cinderella (1997)". IMDB; visited February 2018
  3. Chris Perez. "Meet the biracial twins no one believes are sisters". New York Post. March 2, 2015
  4. "Still Star-Crossed". IMDB; visited February 2018
  5. "Black Remakes of White Films ". BET. October 1, 2012
  6. Dorlean Stevenson. "10 Classic Remakes That Gave Minority Actors The Spotlight". Buzzfeed. March 28, 2014
  7. Christopher Ingraham. "Three quarters of whites don’t have any non-white friends". The Washington Post. August 25, 2014

How Well is Hollywood Rewarding Black Actors/Actresses?

Earlier this year, Mo'Nique complained about the offer Netflix made her, arguing that they undervalued the talent of black female comedians. Mo'Nique may or may not be worth more than what she was offered, but I think she poses an interesting question about pay gaps. Is there a pay gap in Hollywood for black actors or actresses?

Introduction

Earlier this year, Mo'Nique called for a boycott of Netflix over allegations of unfair pay based on race and gender. While I don't necessarily think that was the issue for Mo'Nique (we'll talk details later in the post), it did make me curious about the salaries of black actors and actresses in Hollywood. So many of the movies I've watched staring black actors or actresses are low budget that it seems impossible that they could be raking in the same amount of dough as their white peers. I want to explore this topic.

Mo'Nique

Who is Mo'Nique

If you're black and you have a little age on you, you probably already know who Mo'Nique is and what I'm about to say. For those reading that don't know who Mo'Nique is, I thought I'd provide some background. During the late 90s and early 2000s, Mo'Nique was one of the most popular black comedians in Hollywood. Like other black comedy greats (e.g., Steve Harvey), she was given her own show, The Parkers, in 1999. The Parkers ran for 6 seasons![13] Like Martin (starring Martin Lawerence) and The Steve Harvey Show, my family watched The Parkers all the time.

After launching into a new tier of fame with the success of her show, Mo'Nique began landing roles in movies such as Soul Plane, Hair Show, and Welcome Home Roscoe Jenkins. Her major break came in 2009 when she landed a role in the award wining movie, Precious. Precious was nominated for 6 Academy Awards, one of which was awarded to Mo'Nique (Best Supporting Actress).[12]

At the height of her popularity, Mo'Nique had been given the honor of hosting the BET Awards 3 times.[4] There is no arguing that she was both successful, good at what she does, and a household name.

The Downfall of Mo'Nique

Since Mo'Nique's Oscar win, however, she's been pretty much ghost. Her IMDB page shows a 5 year gap between the time she won the Oscar and her next role. This gap is the evidence of a bitter feud that erupted with Hollywood moguls Oprah and Lee Daniels after the filming of Precious wrapped up. This feud went on to include Tyler Perry.[15] Let's be honest, if you're a black actor or actress, these are the gatekeepers. Most "black" movies are produced by one of these three people. Whatever went down behind the scenes, became even worse when she became vocal about it (Hollywood is like a secret society), and now, Mo'Nique is basically banned from Hollywood.

Mo'Nique vs. Netflix

Recently, Netflix offered Mo'Nique $500,000 for a comedy special. Considering Mo'Nique hasn't had a role since 2016, isn't in the spotlight anymore, and is blackballed in Hollywood, that's actually pretty high (in my opinion). At the height of her fame, I would definitely agree that this is a low ball offer and with an Oscar under her belt, maybe Mo'Nique is worth more than $500K. However, the underlying factor here isn't race or gender, it's politics. The facts are, right or wrong, Mo'Nique made the wrong people mad and it sabotaged her career.

For comparison, Netflix payed legends Chris Rock and Dave Chapelle $20 million for their specials. Commedian Amy Schumer was only offered $11 million, though it is unknown how much she received after negotiating this value. Although Amy Schumer is the first female to make the highest paid commedian's list, she's nowhere near as legendary as Chris Rock or Dave Chapelle.[1][2][7] It would appear that each person was getting what they deserved, but something still isn't quite right...

We know that sexism exists in our world and we know that racism exists. As black women, we get the burden of bearing both of these issues. Companies and industries can "prove" they aren't racist by showing how well the pay or treat black men (e.g., Chris Rock and Dave Chapelle) and they can "prove" they aren't sexist by doing the same for white women (e.g., Amy Schumer), but black women often get lost and remain on the bottom. So tell me, can you name a comedy special on Netflix starring a black woman? What about Tiffany Haddish or Leslie Jones? What about legends like Adele Givens or Sommore?

Comedian Salaries

Photocredit: Unsplash/Vladimir Solomyani
When I think of comedy, I must admit, I think of black comedians. Black people have been stereotyped and pigeonholed in to class clowns and joksters for so long that I'm not surprised many black comedians (Kevin Hart, Will Smith, etc.) are household names. In 2016, Kevin Hart managed to snag the number one spot for highest paid comedian![9] As I said earlier, Amy Schumer is the first and only female to make that list, which means there are no black women on the list. References [7]-[11] provide insight on comedian salaries and awards.

Nuances and Politics

It wasn't long ago that #OscarsSoWhite was trending. There was not a single black nomination in the mix, but in the true spirit of American racism, the Oscars chose the very black Chris Rock to host. They basically said, "but my best firend is black." All month I've been talking about how black characters (and thus black people) are often pushed to the side or only exist in the background. Well, the Oscars are the culmination of this problem.

The same way we expect our good performance in school or at work to garner great letters of recommendation, which in turn help us to gain optimum employment, awards like the Oscar should help actors and actress gain better roles and bigger paychecks. If you haven't guessed by #OscarsSoWhite, black actors and actresses aren't doing so well on that front. Let's talk about 2 acting award shows I think most people are familiar with: The Academy Awards (Oscars) and The Golden Globes.

Oscars

The Academy Awards may be the most prestigious award for actors and actresses. This year marks the 89th award ceremony. The first black person to win an award was Hattie McDaniel for her supporting role in Gone With the Wind in 1939—we're not going to belabor the point that she played Mammy. Black wins for lead roles didn't begin until much later. The first black man to win an Academy Award for Best Actor was Sydney Portier in 1963; only 3 other black actors have won since then (Note: 2 are nominated for the 2017 season but the results are not out yet). The first (and only) woman to win the Academy Award for Best Actress was Halle Berry in 2001.[24]

While black actors and actresses are often awarded for being in the background (supporting roles), it's obvious that they aren't being recognized for being front and center. It's also notable that the only black female to win Best Actress is also very light skinned. The favoring of fairer skinned women in Hollywood is a symptom of colorism. When will we see talented dark skinned women like Lupita N'yongo and Viola Davis winning this award instead of supporting actress?

Golden Globes

This past January marked the 75th Golden Globe Awards, and it was still experiencing firsts for black wins. In 2018 we shouldn't still be seeing "firsts" for blacks in long standing awards or institutions...

Sydney Portier was the first black man to win a Golden Globe for Best Actor in 1962. Diahann Carroll was the first black woman to win Best Actress (for a TV Series) in 1969. January's award show marked the first time a black man has won Best Actor in a Drama TV Series.[20]

In it's 75 year history, only 3 black men have won the title Best Actor in a Motion Picture Drama[18] and only 2 have won Best Actor in a Motion Picture Comedy or Musical.[19] Only two black women have won the title Best Actress in a Motion Picture—Whoopi Goldberg in 1986 (for Drama) and Angela Bassett in 1994 (for Musical or Comedy)—and 5 have won for a TV Series (3 in drama and 2 in Musical or Comedy). Black men have won Best Actor in a Musical or Comedy TV Series 6 times, but no blacks have won Best Director or Best Screenplay.

Just a reminder from the previous post, black people make up about 13% of the population so statistically speaking, we should expect a little less than 10 black winners for each category over 75 years. We really only seen this in categories for supporting roles.[23]

Salaries

As I said, I was curious how the salaries and net worth of black actors and actresses compared to their white peers. Given what I already knew, I assumed "mainstream" actors like Will Smith and Morgan Freeman would have much higher net-worths than black movie favorites like Morris Chestnut or Sean Patrick Thomas. Nonetheless I still expected there to be a significant gap between their net-worths and popular white actors like Leonardo DeCaprio or Tom Cruise

I found a ton of lists about celebrity wealth (apparently we're all obsessed with how much money they have), and I've linked them in the reference section. Here I'm going to focus on the list provided by Huffington Post of the highest paid actors and actresses. To my surprise, Dewayne Johnson (The Rock) and Vin Diesel are the only black actors or actresses on the list and come in 14 and 15th place. In a list specifically for the wealth of actresses, no black actresses were listed.[3][5][6]

References

  1. Karen Mizoguchi. "Amy Schumer On Salary Negotiations: I 'Don't Deserve Equal Pay' to Chris Rock and Dave Chapelle". People. August 24, 2017
  2. Elyse Wenshel. "Amy Schumer Asked Netflix To Up Her Pay After Learning Male Comedians’ Salaries". Huffington Post. August 24, 2017
  3. Natalie Robehmed. "Full List: The World's Highest-Paid Actors And Actresses 2017". Forbes. August 22, 2017
  4. "Top 100 Richest Actors". The Richest; visited February 2018
  5. "GOBankingRates. "20 Highest-Paid Actors of Hollywood Like Robert Downey Jr.". Huffington Post. August 24, 2015
  6. GOBankingRates. "10 of the Richest Actresses of All Time. March 31, 2016
  7. "Top 100 Richest Comedians". The Richest; visited February 2018
  8. "The World's Highest-Paid Comedians". Forbes; visited February 2018
  9. Olivia Blair. "Forbes Highest-Paid comedians: Amy Schumer makes history while Kevin Hart finally topples Jerry Seinfeld". Independent. September 27, 2016
  10. "Grammy Award for Best Comedy Album". Wikipedia; visited February 2018
  11. "American Comedy Awards". Wikipedia; visited February 2018
  12. "The 82nd Academy Awards | 2010". Acadamy Awards. March 7, 2010
  13. "The Parkers". IMDB; visited February 2018
  14. "BET Awards '07 Highlights: Third Time's the Charm for Mo'Nique". BET. June 26, 2007
  15. Christina D'Zurilla. "Mo'Nique slams Lee Daniels, Tyler Perry and Oprah Winfrey in harsh standup riff". LA Times. May 15, 2017
  16. "A History of Emmy - The 1940s". The Emmys; visited February 2018
  17. "Emmy Awards Nominees and Winners". The Emmys; visited February 2018
  18. "Winners & Nominees Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture". Golden Globes; visited February 2018
  19. "Winners & Nominees Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture - Musical or Comedy". Golden Globes; visited February 2018
  20. "Winners & Nominees Best Performance by an Actor In A Television Series - Drama". Golden Globes; visited February 2018
  21. "Winners & Nominees Best Director - Motion Picture". Golden Globes; visited February 2018
  22. "Winners & Nominees Best Screenplay - Motion Picture". Golden Globes; visited February 2018
  23. "List of black Golden Globe Award winners and nominees". Wikipedia; visited February 2018
  24. "List of black Academy Award winners and nominees". Wikipedia; visited February 2018

The Portrayal of Black Superheroes

A revolution seems to be happening in the superhero world. Black Panther is being released this week and it's a big deal. To understand why it's such an anticipated movie, we need to look at the history of black superheroes, both in comic books and in cinema.

Introduction

Although there are many publishers of comics, and even more superheroes, when one hears "superhero" they think of powerhouses DC and Marvel. DC is the creator of household names such as Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, and the Justice League, whereas Marvel is known for Spiderman, X-Men, Captain America, and the Avengers. Unless you're really deep into comics and superheroes, chances are, your favorite superhero comes from one of these universes. Think of your favorite heroes from each of these universes. When it comes to diversity, how does your list of favorite characters stack up?

IGN lists its top 25 superheroes from DC Comics and you guessed it, only 1 of them is black (Cyborg). They manage to include 2 Green Lanterns, and still leave off John Stewart—the black Green Lantern.

Black people make up roughly 13% of the population, but white, non-Hispanic people only make up 60% of the population. If the comic book industry was as diverse as the United States, showing equal care to the storylines of minority characters as white characters, the superheroes on the list would have the following racial makeup: 4 Hispanic, 3 black, 1 Asian, 1 multi-racial, and 16 white characters.[1] Of course, you'd still expect epically awesome superheroes to exist for even smaller minority groups such as Native Americans and Pacific Islanders.

If the list reflected worldwide demographics, these numbers would change even more dramatically! Based on worldwide demographics 61% (15)—more than half—of the superheroes should be Asian. 4 should be from Africa, 3 should be European, 2 from Latin or South America, and 1 from North America.[2]

IGN's top 25 list for Marvel stacks up far better with 4 black superheroes making the list (Black Panther, Storm, Blade, and Luke Cage). Not only does this paint Marvel as more progressive in creating well written diverse characters, all four of these characters, plus a few others, have made it in to their cinematic universe, and Nick Fury, a white man in the comics, was recast as a black man.

Bringing in Black Faces

The difference in diversity across IGN's lists shouldn't surprise you, though. Marvel broke the mold in creating the first mainstream black superhero to have his own comic in mainstream America. That superhero was Black Panther, an African prince from a technologically advanced city, hidden in the midst of Africa. Black Panther was introduced in 1966.[5] For perspective, this was 2 years before my hometown began the process of integration and 3 years after my undergraduate university admitted it's first black student. DC's first black superhero to have his own comic, Black Lightning, wasn't published until 1977—over 10 years later![30]

Firsts for Black Superheroes(in Print)

While Black Panther is widely accepted as the first black superhero to star in a comic of his own, he wasn't the first black superhero to appear in a comic. In fact, he wasn't actually the first to have his own comic. The first black superhero to have his own comic was created in the summer of 1947 by All Negro Comics.[7] All Negro Comics was black owned and operated. That's right, it was a for us, by us moment. It marks the first comic to both feature black heroes as the stars of the comic and to be drawn by black artists.[6] All Negro Comics stared Ace Harlem as an expert detective and Lion Man the first black superhero.

The first black person to appear in a superhero comic, as a supporting character of course, came just a little sooner, probably in 1934. Many credit the appearance of Lothar in Mandrake the Magician as the first black supporting character in a comic. Lothar was not a superhero, and fits neatly into the tropes I've been mentioning all month: he's the main character's sidekick, illiterate, and dresses "exotically."[8][9]

Black Superheroes as Main Characters (in Film)

If you're old enough, you know that Black Panther isn't the first film to have a black man star as the main superhero in cinema history. 20 years ago, there was The Blade Trilogy starring Wesley Snipes as the titular superhero, Blade (also a Marvel superhero). There's also been Hancock, staring Will Smith, Meteor Man (1993) starring Robert Townsend, and Steel (1997) staring Shaq. However, Black Panther is still a first of sorts.

Budget and Promotion

Photocredit: Marvel/Blade
Perhaps it's because I was only 10 when Blade came out, but I don't remember it being given so much promotion from Marvel. Let's look at the numbers to see if it's creation and launch was comparable. Blade had a $45 million dollar budget;[10] Black Panther had a $200 million dollar budget.[11] When Blade was released, there wasn't quite the same furor around superhero movies, nor was computer animation as advanced as it is today. This could explain the massive difference in budget.

So, let's look at other superhero movies that were released during Blade's era. The same year, Marvel released Nick Fury: Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. (with Nick Fury portrayed by a white man) as a television movie. It was never released in theaters. DC's Batman & Robin came out just one year prior, in 1997, but it received a $125 million dollar budget. Before that, Batman Forever, which debuted in 1995, had a budget of $100 million dollars.[19] The Mask of Zorro, —which isn't really a superhero movie, but has many of the same elements as a superhero movie—was released in 1998, and had a $65 million dollar budget.[20]

Now let's look at recent Marvel releases. Captain America: Civil War, the movie Marvel used to introduce Black Panther two years ago, was given an estimated budget of $250 million dollars.[12] Thor: Ragnarok, which was released just last year, only had a budget of $180 million dollars.[13] Spider-Man: Homecoming, also released last year, only had a budget of $175 million dollars.[14]

Although movie budgets were considerably smaller during the time Blade was released, it's budget was still less than the other movies of it's genre for the time period. Black Panther garnered a budget quite comparable to the other Marvel movies being released today.

Photocredit: Marvel/Black Panther
When you consider that characters such as Captain America, Thor, and Spider-Man are all already established in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and were probably household names even before their movies launched, it's a big deal that Black Panther's budget is basically on par with the budgets of these movies. Though Chadwick Boseman (shoutout to my fellow SC native), started his acting career as early as 1970, he is less familiar to a mainstream audience. Prior to being cast as Black Panther for the 2016 Captain America movie, Mr. Boseman had only been in 4 big screen films.[15] Captain America, on the other hand, cast well known actors and actress such as Robert Downey, Jr., Chris Evans (who, fun fact, was actually the Human Torch or Johnny Storm in Fantastic Four),[16] and Scarlett Johansson. That says a lot about the investment the studio place in Black Panther.

The Other Films

Most of the superhero movies starring a black actor that I saw in my youth were more like comedies than superhero movies. Meteor Man, along with the Disney Channel Original movie Up Up and Away, felt like a parody of superhero movies rather than actually superhero movies. Not surprisingly, they both star and were produced by Robert Townsend. Hancock, though not as joke-y as Meteor Man or Up Up and Away, doesn't quite have the superhero feel to it either. Perhaps it's because Hancock is an antihero; he has a bad attitude, is always drunk, and everyone hates him—including the viewer, I can't remember ever actually liking the Hancock character.

TV Shows

If you've been paying attention, you probably noticed that I haven't said much about DC in terms of film. While I can't think of any black DC characters that have made it to the big screen, this year DC comics launched Black Lightning a series about their first black superhero to have his own comic. Marvel's Luke Cage has been on Netflix for a while, as well.

Female Black Superheroes

Photocredit: Lupita Nyong'o in Black Panther
While things seem to be looking up for black men in the world of superheroes, black women aren't fairing nearly as well. X-Men gives us Storm (played by Halle Berry and Alexandra Shipp) and Angel Salvadore (played by Zoë Kravitz). While Storm is a core member of the X-Men team, she's nowhere near as influential to the series or as popular as Professor X and Magneto (even Mystique or Wolverine in the film version). I couldn't even remember the name of Zoë Kravitz's character or which movie she appeared in when I started writing this post, so...yeah, she's not a crucial character. Also, with these two characters we clearly see the effects of colorism. I can't ignore the fact that a dark-skinned female superhero has not graced our screens. The casting of dark skinned women to play pivotal roles, including the love interest, in Black Panther is yet another reason to be excited about it's release.

DC

DC's first African female superhero, was Nubia, who appeared in 1973. For those unfamiliar with Nubia, checkout this video.[21] (Also, now that Wonder Woman was such a box office, can we get a live action Nubia?) DC's first African-American female superhero, Bumblebee, debuted in Teen Titan #48, which was released in 1977. She is now part of the line up in the animated shorts, DC Superhero Girls.[25][26] In 1981, Vixen appeared as a supporting member of the Justice League in DC's universes.[24] Vixen received her own animated series through the CW in 2015. According to IMDB, the series has 2 seasons and 12 episodes.[22][23] To my knowledge, none of these ladies have their own comic series.

Marvel

You're probably already familiar with Storm, a black female superhero from the X-Men series. Storm first appeared in 1975. Though depicted by Halle Berry and Alexandra Shipp in the recent X-Men movies, Storm does not appear to be a light skinned black woman in the comics—though she does have blue eyes and white hair.

Another black female superhero, Misty Knight, actually appeared 3 years earlier than Storm in 1972. She even has an iconic 70's afro, which screams black pride!

The Future of Female Superheroes

As a woman, it saddens me to know that despite the progress we've seen with black male superheroes, women are still trailing behind. I realize that women in general have not been featured as superheroes the same way men have, however, white women are still better represented in this area than black, Latina, and Asian women. Hopefully this current revolution will spill into our realm, as well.

Further Reading

Checkout the following articles, books, and videos for more information.

References

  1. "Census QuickFacts". United States Census Bureau. July 1, 2016
  2. "World Population: Digital Visualization 2014 & Beyond". Population Reference Bureau; visited February 2018
  3. Jesse Schedeen. "The Top 25 Heroes of DC Comics". IGN. November 19, 2013/li>
  4. Joshua Yehl and Jeff Lake. "Top 25 Best Marvel Superheroes". IGN. September 10, 2014
  5. Andrew Wheeler. "Trace the Lineage of Marvel's Black Super Heroes". Marvel. February 28, 2014
  6. "‘All-Negro Comics’, The first Black comic book written and illustrated by Black Americans". The Philadelphia Sunday SUN. February 29, 2016
  7. Jeff Enlow. "Before there were RiRi Williams and Black Panther, there was Lion Man." Timeline. July 6, 2016
  8. "Lothar". Comic Vine; visited February 2018
  9. "Mandrake the Magician". TV Tropes; visited February 2018
  10. "Blade (1998)". IMDB; visited February 2018
  11. Ramin Setoodeh. "Chadwick Boseman and Ryan Coogler on How ‘Black Panther’ Makes History". Variety; visited February 2018
  12. "Captain America: Civil War (2016)". IMDB; visited February 2018
  13. "Thor: Ragnarok (2018)". IMDB; visited February 2018
  14. "Spider-Man: Homecoming". IMDB; visited February 2018
  15. "Chadwick Boseman". IMDB; visited February 2018
  16. "Chris Evans". IMDB; visited February 2018
  17. Nick Fury: Agent of Shield (1998)" .IMDB; visited February 2018
  18. "Batman & Robin (1997)". IMDB; visited February 2018
  19. "Batman Forever (1995)". IMDB; visited February 2018
  20. "The Mask of Zorro (1998)". IMDB; visited February 2018
  21. Essence of Zen. "Who is Nubia | Behind the League". YouTube. February 29, 2016
  22. "Vixen (2015)". IMDB; visited February 2018
  23. D.L. Chandler. "CW Network Announces Animated Black DC Comics Heroine Vixen Series". News One. January 21, 2015
  24. "Vixen". DC Comics; visited February 2018
  25. Amy Ratcliffe. "Get to Know the DC Super Hero Girls: Bumblebee and Katana". DC Comics. March 29, 2016
  26. "Teen Titans #48". eBay; visited February 2018
  27. Princess-India Alexander. "Nubia is the twin sister of 'Wonder Woman' — and she is literally a black queen". Mic. June 15, 2017
  28. "Storm". Marvel; visited February 2018
  29. "Misty Knight". Marvel; visited February 2018
  30. Tim Beedle. "First Look: Black Lightning Comes to Life". DC Comics. March 29, 2017

The Portrayal of Black Characters in Teen Movies

Think about your favorite teen movie. Are there any black character's in it? Can you think of a teen movie that has a black character as the main character that doesn't have an all black cast? Better still, can you think of teen movie with an all black cast that isn't rated R and doesn't deal with gang violence or drugs? Let's talk about the portrayal of black characters in teen movies.

Introduction

I want you to take a minute to think about the movies that defined your adolescence. Which characters were you favorite? Least favorite? Now tell me, are those characters the same race as you? Can you name characters in the movie that are a different race than these characters? Despite the fact that the U.S. is quickly becoming majority minority, our movies still relegate minorities to back court. Since it's black history month let's talk about the portrayal of black characters in teen movies (we'll get to TV shows next time).

Race in Teen Movies

Photocredit: Mean Girls (2004)
I was trying to come up with a list of movies about the teenage experience that had a black main character and struggled so hard I had to enlist Google for help. My mind kept going to the "classics" like The Breakfast Club, Grease, and Mean Girls. Eventually I found a list on BET's website entitled "Ten Best Black High School Movies."[2] BET, which stands for Black Entertainment Television, was co-founded by Robert "Bob" Johnson in 1980 specifically for promoting entertainment that caters to black audiences.[7] So you would think that this would be a solid list right? Except Bob Johnson sold BET to Viacomm, the white owned company that also owns MTV, VH1, and Nickalodeon, in 2000.[8] The list was not at all what I expected.

BET's Top Ten

BET's list has quite a few movies I've never seen (such as Lean on Me and Stand and Deliver) because they came out the same year I was born. Other movies they list, I simply missed because they weren't promoted the same way "mainstream" movies are (part of my whole point). They included movies like Dangerous Minds (white savior trope), Clueless (black character is the best friend of the white main character trope), High School Musical (same trope), Bring It On (aren't the Clovers actually the antagonists?), and Boyz in the Hood.

Movies I Remember

As I thought harder, I came up with Dope, Take the Lead, Light it Up, Let it Shine, Cheetah Girls, Remember the Titans, and Radio.

Tropes

The tropes in these movies are overwhelming. Most of them feature characitures of black life, rooted in stereotypes. A lot of them are the same recycled plot lines and themes. They don't explore the full range of experiences we have as black people.

Inner City Struggles

Photocredit: Dope (2015)
The inner city experience is important to depict and acknowledge, but must it be the only image of black youth we see? Where I grew up, there's really no such thing as a "city," the kids who grew up in the city limits would be considered from the rural in places like Atlanta, Chicago, Los Angeles, or New York. To be honest movies like Boyz in the Hood, Dope, and Light it Up are just as alien to me as The Breakfast Club, Easy A, or The Princess Diaries.

What I find interesting however, is that while I'm comparing these movies, the only similarities they have is that they're about kids in high school. When I think of teen movies, the likes of which churn out teen heart throbs (like the movies that starred Lindsay Lohan, Chad Michael Murray, etc., during my teen years), I think of movies that are targeting teenagers. The target audience is kids, that means 13 - 18 years old; needless to say most of them are rated PG-13. There's something angsty, a romance plot (probably even a triangle), and adults getting in the way of your dreams. Boyz in the Hood, Dope and Light it Up, contain these themes, but are all rated R. This means that to see it in theaters, you had to be 17 or your parents had to buy the ticket for you. It also makes you stop and ask if it was actually made for black youth or for black adults reminiscing about their youth?

Don't get me wrong, I thoroughly enjoyed movies, but I'm pretty sure I was out of high school before I saw Boyz in the Hood and I was definitely out of high school when I saw Dope. Regardless, these movies are serious social commentaries on the serious struggles facing teens in the inner city; they're nowhere as lighthearted as say Freaky Friday or 13 Going on 30.

White Saviors

Photocredit: Freedom Writers (2007)
Notice anything interesting about the movie poster?
Since Hollywood decided we're all living on the streets, struggling with gangs, and living with drug addicted parents, we must need stories that show us overcoming these struggles, right? And who better than to pick us up out of the gutter than a well intentioned white person from the upper middle class? Take the Lead, Freedom Writers, The Blindside, Radio and Dangerous Minds, all tell this sad story. Ok, so in Take the Lead, Antonio Banderas is the "white savior" and some people might not consider him "white" but he's not white passing—he's from Spain; he's white.[3]

I've seen all of these movies—I actually own Take the Lead (awesome soundtrack!) and Freedom Writers—but once again, they pigeonhole us (and other minorities, because those are usually the other classmates shown) as being misunderstood hoodlums that need white people to show us better.

In Take the Lead and Freedom Writers, the lone white student is met with open hostilty, which is probably why Mean Girls refers to the black people as unfriendly in the infamous cafeteria scene. They always paint us as rude, mean, and unaccepting, but in movies like High School Musical, 10 Things I Hate About You, and Clueless, the black best friend exists in a world where there is no racism... How Sway!?

Black Man = Athlete

Photocredit: She's the Man (2006)
No black main characters,
but the love interest has black friend on the team
If we're not in a movie about the inner city, you can best believe sports are involved some how. According to Hollywood, black people can definitely be found in your high school's athletic department. No? Radio, The Blindside, Remember the Titans, Jump In, Coach Carter, and High School Musical all feature sports. I'd give High School Musical credit for the character of Taylor, a black female in the science club, but I had to look up her name and the franchise didn't launch her career the way it did for Vanessa Hudgens, Zac Efron, Ashley Tisdale, and Lucas Grabeel.

Think about this: in both High School Musical and Jump In, Disney cast Corbin Bleu as an athlete, first as a basketball player, then as a boxer. Corbin Bleu is a professional dancer, singer, and model; while he's in shape, he doesn't looks like a jock at all.

Think about this: Michael Oher, the man The Blindside was based on, doesn't really like the way the movie depicts him.[4].

Do you think it's a coincidence that all my black male friends who went to college with me were asked what sport they play on a regular basis? I mean, what kind of black man goes to school and doesn't play sports, right?

Entertainers

Photocredit: Bring it On (2000)
At least Gabrielle Union made it on the poster
When we aren't being portrayed as athletes, Hollywood ops for entertainers instead: You Got Served, Roll Bounce, Cheetah Girls, Drumline, Let it Shine. These movies focus on showmanship and the fact that "all black people can sing and dance." You Got Served manages to throw in some inner city drama, show our mostly black main characters trying to overcome the mostly white group that stole their moves, and provide horrible acting (I'm ashamed to say I liked this movie when it came out!). It's basically the male version of Bring it On told from the black team's perspective.

Speaking of Bring it On, it fits in this category too. You could argue the Clovers (the black cheerleading squad) are athletic since they do flips and stunts, but the crux of the movie is on their dance moves, style, and of course, attitude (re: showmanship). Plus, the Clovers are portrayed as the antagonists even though they're the underdogs? Yet, the movie wants us to root for the white squad as though they're the underdogs... Why couldn't we get the movie as an underdog story from the Clover's side instead?
I know you didn't think a white girl came up with those moves Gabrielle Union's character Isis

As a band geek, I love Drumline. We get to see an HBCU and a band director who wants to focus on music over showmanship. I used to be able to quote this movie word for word from beginning to end. The point of this post isn't to say these are horrible movies, but to remind you that this isn't the only type of movie we should get. Drumline features a predominately black cast and focuses on black musicianship at HBCUs, but how does a talented black musician, like Devon, fit in white musical spaces? Movie wise, think Raise Your Voice, a movie about teens at an elite music camp staring Hilary Duff. The black character is pushed off to the side. It's not her story, it's Hilary Duff's; she just happens to be there. Real life wise, I want to see the come up story of someone like Misty Copeland.

Photocredit: The Cheetah Girls (2003)
The Cheetah Girls is another series that I enjoyed. Even though it's about entertainment, the cast is diverse both ethnically and economically. For once, the minority characters are the ones with money, and it's the white character who lives in a foster home. Thankfully, they still give her great story lines and make her the stellar dancer of the group. Each girl has her own personality and style. Of course, there are still things to mention. For one, Aqua (played by Kiely Williams) is the only character in the group that is fully black and we never meet her parents. She also tends to get attitude-y (sassy black girl stereotype). For two, over the course of three movies we get 2 white love interests and an Indian love interest, but no black love interests. (Yay, for interracial dating though!) The only black guy to show up in the series is the sidekick of the love interest, and of course he's a hip-hop DJ.

The Best Friend

Photocredit: Clueless (1995)
Most mainstream teen movies feature a white character main character who has a black best friend. Clueless, High School Musical, Another Cinderella Story, Starstruck, Freaky Friday, Step Up, etc. If the black character is the main character, there's a big chance the whole cast is black and most white people have never seen it. Buzzfeed made a ranking of 27 "classic" teen movies from 2000,[5] can you guess how many of them have a black main character? None of them feature a black character as the main character and only 7 of them have black characters at all. Of those 7 movies, 6 feature a black best friend. The exception is Bring it On which features the mostly black cheerleading squad as antagonists. Save the Last Dance has a mostly black cast, but stars Julia Stiles as the main character learning to fit in to their inner city world, and naturally she makes a black best friend. Buzzfeed also has list of "classic" family movies, it garners slightly more movies that feature a black main character, but not many.[1] There's also Seventeen Magazine's list of 20 must see teen movies. 3 of those movies have black characters (still all secondary characters). It also has contains 17 Again, not to be confused with the mostly black Seventeen Again staring Tia and Tamera Mowry with basically the same plot.[6]

The Bigger Issue

Despite the fact that we shouldn't try to emulate TV, there's already proof that images in the media negatively affect the way young girls see themselves. Negative body images are a direct result of the media promoting certain body types over others. Black teens have even less positive representation in the media. These movies reinforce stereotypes and even worse, heavily favor lighter skinned black women over dark skinned black women. We know major networks like Disney churn out teen stars; from Justin Timberlake and Brittany Spears to Miley Cyrus and Selena Gomez. But what about black teen stars? Can you name any black teen stars backed by these networks? Did they end up successful? Just think about the multiple movies and shows afforded to the Olson twins versus the few movies that featured Tia & Tamera Mowry. I can't tell you if life is imitating art or if art is imitating life, but it definitely says some thing that when you think classic teen movies, black characters are either absent all together, or playing second fiddle.

References

  1. Ellie Bate. "Have You Seen At Least 50/98 Of These Classic Family Movies?". Buzzfeed. February 9, 2018
  2. "Ten Best Black High School Movies". BET. September 6, 2012
  3. "Antonio Banderas". Wikipedia; visited February 2018
  4. David Newton. "Michael Oher doesn't like 'The Blind Side,' but Panthers teammates love movie, and him". ESPN. January 21, 2016
  5. Tabatha Leggett, Rossalyn Warren, and Ailbhe Malone. "A Ranking Of 27 Classic ’00s Teen Movies, From Worst To Best". Buzzfeed. July 18, 2014
  6. Noelle Devoe. 20 Best Teen Movies You Can't Grow Up Without Watching". Seventeen. October 3, 2017
  7. "Robert L. Johnson". Wikipedia; visited February 2018
  8. "Viacomm". Wikipedia; visited February 2018

DON'T MISS

Book Review,Food,Testimony
© 2022 all rights reserved
made with by templateszoo